He had never entered the theater.
A forensic examination found particles from the crosswalk’s yellow curb paint on one of his shoes.
Investigators also recovered deleted searches from his laptop: payout timelines for child life insurance, whether a spouse could sell a jointly owned house with power of attorney, and how long traffic cameras retained footage.
The unknown number in the messages belonged to a prepaid phone found in Barbara’s kitchen drawer.
At first, Barbara insisted Andrew had used the phone without her knowledge.
Then investigators recovered her fingerprints from the device and located messages she had sent from her regular phone telling him when Katie left for practice.
Her attorney later claimed she believed Andrew only intended to frighten Katie into keeping quiet about the insurance policy.
No one believed that explanation.
The most damaging evidence came from Andrew himself.
During questioning, he attempted to portray me as unstable and Katie as confused.
